Transphobic Assault on a Woman in Queens

Trigger Warning

Earlier this week, yet another trans woman was assaulted in a transphobic hate crime.  Carmella Etienne was attacked on Wednesday night while walking home from the store. Two men started yelling slurs at her, threatened to kill her and rape her with a baseball bat, and then threw rocks and a beer bottle at her.  Carmella sustained a deep cut on her leg, and says that she is now afraid to leave her house.

The men have been arrested and charged with a hate crime.  I want to say first of all that I’m glad and relieved that the police department in this case has had a proper and respectful response to Ms. Etienne’s allegations.  Far too often, indeed I’m willing to go out on a limb and say a majority of the time, it’s just not the case, and police will dismiss assaults against transgender individuals, and often ridicule and/or assault the victim themselves.  This is especially the case when the victim is also a woman of color.  And that’s not even to mention all of the cases — also a majority, I’m sure — which are never reported for fear of that kind of response.  When Carmella announced that she was calling the police, her attackers responded that “the police don’t care about you, they won’t do anything to us.”  The sad fact is that in most circumstances they would have been correct.  So good for the police for proving them wrong for once by seemingly doing their jobs.

It’s unsurprising that a friend of the alleged assailants not only claims that her friends did not commit the hateful acts of violence, but chooses to additionally engage in transphobia and victim-blaming as a part of the defense.  The woman misgenders Carmella by using masculine pronouns, stereotypes her behavior based on her gender identity, and claims that the victim’s behavior is also responsible for the attack.

It’s particularly interesting and noteworthy to compare the friend’s statement to those found in the comments at Gothamist, where I originally found this story.  Though not engaging in overt victim-blaming, about half of the commenters feel the need and right to make transphobic remarks about Carmella’s gender by portraying it as illegitimate, to engage in trans misogynistic slurs and judgments about her appearance, and to refer to her as a “thing.”  Not only do they feel the need and right to do these things, they feel the need and right immediately after a violent attack on the woman they’re disparaging.  They feel that attacks on her gender identity and appearance are indeed an appropriate response to an article about that violent assault.

It’s worth noting that the physical attack on Carmella began with a verbal attack based in the exact same prejudices found in the comment thread.  Both aim to ridicule and thereby devalue the victim based on her identity as a person.  And we really shouldn’t be surprised when these kinds of attempts to devalue a person’s worth and right to be treated with basic dignity also lead to and end in violence.

0 thoughts on “Transphobic Assault on a Woman in Queens

  1. queen emily

    ‘Tis almost always the way – the collective cis response to transphobic violence is to repeat the same ideas that lead to the violence in the first place, legitimizing it after the fact.

    You’re right, the amazing thing in this story is that she reported the assault in the first place, and that the police took her seriously. *That* fills me with confidence, regardless of the predictable transphobic backlash.

  2. Pingback: Femmostroppo Reader – July 13, 2009 — Hoyden About Town

  3. Fi

    One person makes the comment that without a uterus and ovaries, she is a man with no plumbing. By that reasoning, a woman with ovarian cancer who got them removed is not a woman? What an ass.

    The entire comment section makes me sick.

    1. Cara Post author

      Indeed, Fi, but I’m sure that if called on that, the writer would come up with some kind of bullshit loophole. The point really isn’t about a huge attachment to the idea of a woman being a person with a uterus, but about drawing arbitrary standards that always keep trans women out of their version of the category of woman.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s