Texas Prisons Have Nation’s Highest Rates of Sexual Abuse

Last month, I wrote a post about the enormous problem of prison rape in the U.S. and the complacency of both the public and the officials in charge of ensuring it doesn’t happen. The Houston Chronicle has just recently profiled the problem itself as pertaining to Texas, and the situation in the state is extraordinarily dire and apparently the worst in the nation:

Each week, the staff of the prison watchdog group Just Detention International receives about 30 letters from inmates who say they’ve been sexually assaulted in prisons across the country.

More than a quarter of those letters come from one state: Texas.

Sexual abuse is a problem in prisons from Rikers Island to Albany. But even when adjusted for the number inmates in a given prison system, Texas still stands out as the state where sexual assault in prison is most prevalent.

Five of the 10 prisons with the highest rates of sexual abuse in the country are in Texas. That includes the top two, Estelle Unit and Clements Unit.

The alarming rank of the Estelle Unit, on FM 3478 in Huntsville, came after the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics surveyed inmates in hundreds of state and federal prisons, as well as county lockups, for the new law.

Nationwide, the rate of inmates reporting sexual victimization within a prior 12-month period was 4.5 percent. At Estelle, it was 15.7 percent.

Four other Texas prisons were in the top 10, including the Clements Unit in Amarillo, the Allred Unit near Wichita Falls, the Mountain View Unit near Gatesville, and the Coffield Unit near Tennessee Colony. Those prisons had rates of abuse from 9.3 to 13.9 percent.

Considering that 4.5 percent of inmates being assaulted within the past 12 months is already a staggering and hugely unacceptable figure, those prisons with rates that soar so high above this average are clearly doing something wrong. And since, as discussed in the last post, a large majority of assaults are committed not by fellow inmates but by prison guards, there’s also likely a whole lot more going on than bad policy.

On the surface, it seems that the state has taken some positive steps towards prevention and accountability. But it also seems that such measures may be little more than public relations efforts, both because of the high rates of assault still occurring and because officials are still making excuses and engaging in rape myths:

Texas officials say that the rates of abuse reflected in that report may have been artificially inflated by the report’s methodology, which recorded inmates’ complaints without attempting to verify their validity.

State prison personnel say they’ve already made progress in educating prisons’ employees and inmates alike about the need to combat sexual abuse and the options that are available to them if they’ve already been attacked.

Texas is the only state in the country to have a special prosecution unit that specializes in crimes committed in prisons. And the state has implemented the Safe Prisons Program, designed to educate inmates about sexual assault and separate likely abusers from potential victims.

“Texas is actually at the forefront of trying to stop sexual violence in prisons,” prosecutor Gina DeBottis said.

If officials wanted to argue that their programs have been so successful that rates of victims reporting sexual assault are just much, much higher than in other states, I’d be incredibly dubious of their claims, but at least the stance could be considered somewhat defensible.  Instead, they seem to have opted rather disgracefully for a position that looks an awful lot like the old rape apologist standby “lying bitches lie about rape, because they’re filthy bitch liars.”

The idea that reports of sexual violence are just so much higher in Texas because prisoners in that state are not only making up stories, but doing so uniquely and en masse, is more than just ludicrous. It’s also grossly irresponsible and serves no purpose but to shame victims and cast a skeptical light on the stories of all sexual assault survivors, for the sole purpose of really poorly defending the corrections system that is causing these assaults in the first place.

That these statements are what Texas officials chose to release very sadly shows that, unsurprisingly, they are more concerned with protecting their own reputations than they are with protecting the human rights of those who are in their care and at their mercy. A responsible, measured response would have involved an admission that what the state is currently doing is clearly not working, the pledge to do something different, and an outline of what steps would be taken to determine what that something is and implement it. Instead, it’s the same old story: excuses, denials, and minimization.

And the depressing fact of the matter is that these numbers are useless if officials aren’t willing to act on them, or the public doesn’t care enough to make them act.

As a final note, I want to touch on this short section of the article:

Not all sex between corrections officers and inmates is coerced; 6 percent of Clements inmates reported consensual sex with staff. But even if an inmate is willing to have sex with a corrections officer, it is illegal.

Because of guards’ position of power over their charges, prisoners cannot legally consent to sex with corrections officers. In Texas, corrections officers can be — and DeBottis says often are — prosecuted for any sexual contact with an inmate, including kissing.

There is excellent reason for these laws to be in place, and “consensual” is not exactly the right word for these encounters. Firstly, a lot of rapes committed through coercion, pressure, and power differentials are not commonly seen as rape, even by the victims. That doesn’t mean the rape isn’t traumatizing, merely that in a society that only sees sexual contact obtained through physical force as assault (and even then still only sometimes), the words to describe these experiences often aren’t in victims’ vocabularies. As one such victim, though not in a prison setting, the words certainly weren’t in mine.

Secondly, even if the prisoners described here genuinely desired sexual contact with the guards — and I do not deny that this is possible — the guards who agreed to such contact were still committing an act of abuse. We are talking about prisoners. And regardless of whether or not there is good reason for these prisoners to be prisoners, the fact remains that these guards are their captors. In such a position of extreme and consequential power difference, a prisoner can experience genuine desire for sexual contact, but cannot meaningfully consent to it and all that it entails. And a guard can reciprocate such desire without acting on it, as a matter not only of law but of ethics. The alternate act is an abuse of power. And abuse of power, as is right there in the name, is abuse. Abuse of power enacted sexually is also necessarily sexual abuse. Period.

0 thoughts on “Texas Prisons Have Nation’s Highest Rates of Sexual Abuse

  1. kaninchenzero

    I’m so not surprised. Despairing of my state absolutely yes. Not at all surprised. It’s not just policy. It’s not just a culture amongst corrections officers encouraging abuse of prisoners. It’s the whole fucking culture here period. Prisoners deserve to be raped in prison. It’s an expected part of the punishment. (No one in the world considers rehabilitation a possibility even in the juvenile criminal system. Prison here is punishment. Retribution. Vengeance-by-proxy.) Nice White People here would be disappointed if prisoners weren’t raped.

  2. BLUE

    @kaninchenzero….too true. I have two members on one side of my family that were correctional officers both of them have worked at Estelle at one time or another. There are plenty of officers who think, “Well, they’re here so they’re bad people so they deserve what happens in here.” Also the Estelle unit could have more problems becuase of it’s a little bit of everything status. They are rated for G1-5 population and they have special needs too. They also run alot workshop and farming so there’s alot of activity to be watching at any one time.

  3. Thealogian

    Its amazing how much its assumed in mass-media, specifically on comedy shows, that going to prison equals (and more scary should equal) expected rape of the inmate. Once in a class I was teaching some of my non-traditional students (women in their 40’s) said that if you’re in prison you deserve to be raped, especially the child molesters. Essentially in these women’s world view (Southeastern US) if you go to prison, 1. you are probably a child molester, 2. you lose all bodily autonomy and right to safety. I pointed out that the majority of men getting raped in prison are youngish men (late teens/early 20’s) who are there for a variety of offenses, most especially drug possession. Men in prison for rape and the molestation of children are RAPING AND MOLESTING RECENT CHILDREN. Also, the fact that a rapist is a rapist no matter who he rapes therefore making an environment conductive to continued rape is a really bad idea doesn’t seem to register either.

  4. Pingback: Tell the Department of Justice to Adopt New Standards to Address Prison Rape — The Curvature

  5. Pingback: Justice Department to Miss Deadline for New Standards to Address Prison Rape — The Curvature

  6. Pingback: Jail Guard Arrested on Charges of Sexually Assaulting Trans Woman Inmate — The Curvature

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s